
We here at The Puzzleboy Ltd. (a division of Puzzleboy Unltd.) have a corporate policy that extends across every branch of our multi-pronged conglomerate: If we make a mistake, no we didn’t.
So, yes: if you’ve been a subscriber to this newsletter since May 1st, you may have received two wildly different versions of this puzzle on two consecutive days, and yes, our The Puzzleboy might have been up until the wee hours on a Friday night sweating and cursing at a fake baseball team that he invented, but here’s the important thing: we all got through it and we’re all stronger for it.
In other words: sorry!
Without further ado, here’s how to solve this Balkdle. (Also, while we’re at it, I’m still not happy with that name. If you have a better baseball-related/ends with the suffix “-dle” suggestion, I’d love to hear it.)
There are many, many ways to go about solving this puzzle. Once you crack an initial clue, like Ryan Taggert is the pitcher, you can pretty quickly learn that the Nashville Stars player is the pitcher, and so on and so forth.
For that reason, I don’t think there’s a great method to show an exact path to get to the conclusion. There are many. Instead, here’s our final grid.
Player | Team | Year | Position | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Nolan Mercer | Indianapolis Racers | 2010 | First Base | Texas Tech |
Danny Kowalski | Omaha Plainsmen | 2016 | Catcher | LSU |
Brett Holloway | Salt Lake Peaks | 2019 | Third Base | Arizona State |
Chase Underwood | Montreal Voyageurs | 2020 | Center Field | Cal State Fullerton |
Ryan Taggart | Nashville Stars | 2024 | Pitcher | Vanderbilt |

Suh-wing, puzzlers! Puzzleboy Pantheon! Congrats to all!
Alex S.: 5
Anne E.: 5
Audrey A.: 5
Colleen N.: 5
Cyrus H.: 5
Dan C.: 5
Erin K.: 5
Helene L.: 5
Jay W.: 5
Jennifer K.: 5
Jeremy B.: 5
Kari A.: 5
Kelvin Y.: 5
Kristen K.: 5
Laurie F.: 5
Luke S.: 5
Maxim L.: 5
Matt M.: 5
Rakedu T.: 5
Tim M.: 5
Trace G.: 5
Dan B.: 4.75
Jesse F.: 4.5
Edward W.: 4.25
Robin L.-F.: 4.25
Series Three had a crazy Opening Day but you’re all hittin’ dingers! Next month, there will be absolutely no technical snafus for The Puzzleboy. Join us on June 1st for *checks notes* oh, dear:


